NSCG

Where will your building society’s next Chief Risk Officer come from?

Dan Boneham | 17 November 2026

Where will your building society’s next Chief Risk Officer come from?

And who should own that decision?

Over the last 15 years, I’ve worked with the majority of the UK’s building societies and largely on second-line leadership: risk, compliance and financial crime, alongside the internal audit teams that assure them. That’s given me a close view of how risk functions are built, where the strain shows, and what happens when the CRO seat falls empty.

With several recent mandates I have gained a strong picture of where the people running risk at every UK building society came from. Across all the societies with a standalone risk leader, just one is a sitting Chief Risk Officer who stepped up from a smaller society to a bigger one.

I’m a big advocate of promoting from within, and it should always be the first option. But when there’s no successor ready, boards tend to skip straight past the proven CROs running risk at smaller societies.

That led me to a bigger question. When a building society needs a new CRO, who actually owns the decision? It is surprising how many boards couldn’t give a straight answer.

Where risk leaders come from

I’ve spoken with a large number of senior risk leaders across the sector over the years and I mapped where the most senior risk leader at each society came from.

Fewer than one in three were promoted from within. When boards looked outside, nearly 60% hired from beyond the building society sector altogether: banks, specialist lenders, consulting, housing and insurance. Only around one in seven were already a CRO at another society and almost all of those moved sideways or to a smaller society.

The traffic mostly runs downhill. People leave banks and bigger societies to run risk at smaller ones, often because it’s the fastest route to the top seat. Many of them have since run the whole function themselves, answering to the board and the regulator. Yet the route back up is almost closed.

Who owns the decision?

The rules spread CRO succession across at least four places and none of them clearly owns the appointment.

  • The chief executive is usually the CRO’s day-to-day line manager and in practice, usually runs the hire.
  • The chair of the risk committee is responsible under the senior managers regime for safeguarding the independence of the risk function and overseeing its performance, including the CRO’s.
  • The nominations committee, under the UK Corporate Governance Code that societies have regard to, is meant to make sure succession plans exist for senior management.
  • The board must approve a CRO’s removal.

So, the rules say who protects the CRO’s independence, who must approve their removal and who should have a plan. None of them say who chooses the CRO.

In most societies, the chief executive fills that gap. That’s understandable, and it often works. But it means the person whose decisions the CRO exists to challenge usually picks who does the challenging. Research from Bayes Business School, based on interviews with 31 UK CROs, found many now see themselves as partners to the chief executive. That’s healthy up to a point, and it’s exactly the tension a board should weigh when it chooses the next one.

My view is that the risk committee chair should hold the pen on the brief and sign off the shortlist. The chief executive should be a genuine co-owner, not the sole decision maker. The CPO should run the process and the nominations committee should make sure there’s a plan before anyone resigns. I’d be interested to hear how boards approach this in practice. What works well in your society and what could others learn from your experience?

Who sits in the risk committee chair’s seat?

If the risk committee chair should have a bigger say, it’s worth knowing who they are. So, I looked at who chairs the risk committee across the sector.

Around half built their executive careers in banking. The rest come from consulting and audit, insurance, the regulator and elsewhere, with building society careers a small minority. Circa 25% have been a CRO in financial services themselves, which is a real strength: they know the job from the inside. But former building society CROs are almost absent from the chair’s seat.

That isn’t a criticism of anyone. It’s a question every risk committee should be willing to ask itself. If the people closest to the decision built their careers in banks, a bank CV will look familiar and a small-society CV may look small. Are we recognising experience that looks like ours and missing experience that doesn’t?

Why smaller society CROs get overlooked?

Some of the reasons are fair. Some aren’t.

Breadth gets read as smallness. A CRO at a small society often holds SMF 4, 16 and 17 together: risk, compliance oversight and money laundering reporting. At the top of the sector those sit with three different people. Some boards see someone who has answered for everything. Others see proof the job was small.

They’re hard to see. Small risk teams mean little time for the conference circuit and little profile outside their region. When a bigger society goes to market, the shortlist fills with names that are easy to find and those tend to be in banks.

A bank name feels safe. Hiring from a big bank looks like buying scale. But a bank head of risk has often run one slice of a huge function and never owned the whole job in front of a board.

Geography is real. Societies are regional, and a CRO in Cumbria may not move to Swansea. That’s a fair constraint, but it doesn’t explain the whole pattern.

Scale is a genuine step. A bigger society brings more complex funding, bigger teams and closer supervisory attention. It’s also the part of the job that’s easiest to learn with a good team around you.

One point should count in their favour. A sitting CRO has already been through the regulator’s approval process for the role. That’s less regulatory risk than a first-time CRO, not more.

Why this matters now..

Three things have shifted in the past year.

  • In December 2025 the PRA withdrew the building-society-specific supervisory statement on treasury and lending. Societies are now expected to meet the same risk management standards as banks and to design their own frameworks without a prescribed template. That puts more weight on the CRO’s judgement.
  • The cost of meeting those standards falls hardest on the smallest. The Building Societies Association’s research, published in July, puts compliance costs at £644 per £1m of assets for small societies against £56 for the largest.
  • The talent pool is tight. In Teneo’s 2026 survey of UK financial services CROs, 87% reported a capability gap in risk talent.

And the bench is thin. Fewer than one in three societies filled the seat internally and at the very smallest there’s no standalone risk leader at all; risk sits with the finance director or a manager.

Rethinking the interim..

Most boards treat an interim CRO as a stopgap. I’d argue it’s one of the best tools a board has for getting the permanent decision right.

Where interims have worked, they’ve done more than hold the seat. Graeme Forrester was interim CRO at Coventry Building Society through its acquisition of the Co-operative Bank, then joined Principality as interim CRO during its transformation and was confirmed in the permanent role in April. At Tesco Bank, an interim CRO appointed in 2021 was made permanent later that year. NatWest appointed an interim Group CRO in January while it searched for a permanent successor.

A good interim buys a board time to run a proper search, including the smaller-society pool, rather than reaching for the first familiar name. It can also help test a step-up hire: the PRA’s own guidance contemplates time-limited approvals, with conditions attached, while a permanent arrangement is settled.

Questions worth asking before the seat is empty

Chief executives: if your CRO resigned tomorrow, would you run the search, and would your board be comfortable that you did?

Risk committee chairs: you’re accountable for the independence and performance of the risk function. How much say do you actually have over who leads it?

CPOs: does your succession plan for the CRO name people, or does it just say “external search”?

CROs: who in your team could do your job in 18 months, and what would they need to get there? And if you wanted to step up, would a bigger society take you seriously?

What I’d do as we approach a very interesting 2027 in the Sector:

  1. Back your internal successor first and invest in them properly. If there isn’t one, that’s a resourcing question as much as a hiring one, and it belongs on the risk committee’s agenda.
  2. Agree who owns the CRO appointment: who writes the brief, who signs off the shortlist and who makes the final call. Write it down.
  3. Know the CROs one size below you who could do the job, and decide now how your board reads combined senior manager functions.
  4. Know who would hold the seat on an interim basis before you need them.

The best CRO for your society might already be doing the job, just somewhere smaller. Whether your board finds them may come down to who’s holding the pen.

I’ve mapped all 42 societies: where their risk leaders came from and who chairs their risk committees.

That picture is a starting point for a wider conversation – not just about who you hire next, but how you develop your leaders and plan for succession. At NSCG, we bring together talent acquisition, leadership consulting and succession planning to help boards think beyond the next appointment. If you’d like to see where your society sits, or talk through what comes next, drop me a message.

Share this:
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.